McKinsey PEI: The complete guide to acing the Personal Experience Interview
What is McKinsey PEI?
The PEI is McKinsey’s structured behavioral interview. You will go deep on one high‑impact story while the interviewer probes your decisions, tradeoffs, and leadership behaviors. It appears in every round and is often the tiebreaker. Many rejections come from the PEI, not the case.
Format and timing
- PEI usually runs 10–20 minutes inside each interview.
- One main story per interview; different themes across rounds.
- Depth over breadth with targeted follow up questions.
How many stories?
Prepare a bank of 4–6 stories and label each by primary theme plus a backup theme.
The four PEI dimensions
Learn McKinsey’s language and build a calibrated story for each theme.
Inclusive Leadership
Bring people together, create psychological safety, coach peers. Expect follow‑ups on influencing without authority and conflict resolution.
Personal Impact
Change decisions and outcomes. Show stakeholder mapping, crisp communication, and measurable results.
Entrepreneurial Drive
Set ambitious goals and persevere under constraints. Emphasize ownership, bias to action, and resilience.
Courageous Change
Challenge the status quo, take principled stands, lead difficult change. Expect questions on risk and tradeoffs.
Structure your answer with STARR
Keep Situation + Task to 30–45s. Spend time on Action, Results, and Reflection; that is where probing happens.
Sample STARR outline you can copy
Situation: Our product renewal rate dropped in the UK region during Q3.
Task: I owned a 90‑day plan to recover churn by 4 percent without extra headcount.
Action:
- Mapped churn drivers by segment and ran quick win tests with sales and support.
- Reframed the conversation with the regional GM who opposed pricing changes. I showed a simple sensitivity model and proposed a low‑risk pilot.
- Coached two account managers who struggled with renewal objections, set weekly role play sessions, and tracked conversion steps.
Results: Renewal improved by 5.3 percent in 8 weeks, revenue up 640 thousand, pilot expanded to two more regions.
Reflection: I paired data with narrative for skeptics and codified coaching into team routines. I reused the playbook the next quarter in Germany with similar results.
Prompts to mine your experience
Inclusive Leadership
Turned around a low‑morale team; resolved conflict across functions; coached a struggling peer to a measurable improvement.
Personal Impact
Shifted a senior decision with data and framing; won support from a skeptical client under pressure; secured budget or scope change.
Entrepreneurial Drive
Launched an initiative with minimal resources; rescued a failing project via rapid tests; kept a team motivated through setbacks.
Courageous Change
Raised a hard issue others avoided; stopped a popular but wrong plan; called a risk early and aligned stakeholders to pivot.
How to prepare: fast and well
Pick the right moments
Choose high‑stakes stories with real obstacles and measurable outcomes. Ambiguity and conflict are your friends.
Write in STARR
Keep S + T short. Make Action a numbered sequence of decisions. Results = numbers or observable change. Reflection = honest and specific.
Tag & practice
Label each story by primary and secondary theme. Practice with interruptions every 20–30s to train depth on “how” and “why.”
Collect receipts
Have metrics, stakeholder quotes, or timeline inflection points ready to reference without breaching confidentiality.
See what CaseLane can do for you
AI practice and proven workflows to move faster with confidence.
- AI case and PEI practice
- Resume/CV scoring and templates
- LinkedIn on steroids: PeopleLane networking
What interviewers really probe
- Why you chose that approach over viable alternatives
- Exactly how you influenced a resistant stakeholder
- The toughest conflict and the words you used
- What you would do differently now and why
- Where you misread the room and how you recovered
Likely PEI questions
- Tell me about a time you led a team through conflict.
- Describe a situation where you changed a senior stakeholder’s mind.
- Give an example of a bold change you championed.
- Share a time you pursued an ambitious goal despite obstacles.
- When did you have to influence without formal authority?
- Tell me about a time you made a mistake, what you learned, and what you changed.
PEI vs fit interview
Many firms stay high level in fit interviews. McKinsey centers on one story and tests decision quality, leadership behaviors, and reflection with rigorous follow ups. Generic answers will not hold under probing; STARR with receipts will.
US and Europe nuance
Core dimensions are identical. Some European offices probe team dynamics and stakeholder context more; US offices often push on ownership and measurable impact. STARR works in both.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Vague outcomes. Replace “it went well” with numbers or observable changes.
- Team only credit. Own your decisions and consequences.
- Long backstory. Keep the setup short and move to actions.
- Skipping Reflection. Show growth and self awareness.
- Inventing stories on the spot. Use prepared, pressure tested stories.
FAQs
Want to ace your consulting interviews?
Join CaseLane to access our complete library of case interview resources, AI-powered feedback, and get referred to top consulting firms.
Sign up / Sign in